Thirty-five people in British Columbia died from fentanyl in November. Nine died on one day. The responsibility for these 35 fentanyl deaths lies with our draconian prohibition laws.
Humans have altered their consciousness with substances since before Christ. Many of us do it today with state-sanctioned drugs like alcohol or prescription pills. People like to get high, creating a demand for substances which are not provided by the state. That’s the reality that we have to live with.
Some portion of the population is going to use criminalized substances for recreation, just as some will abuse tobacco and alcohol, despite the widespread knowledge of their respective harms.
To the degree that we criminalize substance use with the threat of punishment, the more we create the necessary conditions for a black market. A black market is a pure market because it is unrestrained by the state. Contracts and agreements are enforced by violence, intimidation and bribery. Market share is determined by the law of the jungle. Demand is not reduced by enforcement because the black market responds to counteract all and any of those efforts.
One of the responses to drug enforcement is for producers to deliver “more bang for the buck”. This means packaging dosages in smaller units to avoid detection, and generating higher revenues for every gram produced. This type of drug marketing is little different than how liquor is sold in retail outlets: the tiny bottles by the till are not full of beer, but rather a few ounces of scotch, rye or tequila. Marketing one or two ounce bottles promotes impulse buying, is more profitable, and can be concealed by buyers for illegal consumption in public.
Powdered cocaine morphed into crack cocaine because of the pressure applied by law enforcement on the Colombian drug cartels in the 1980s. US drug traffickers distilled crack from cocaine to make smaller units which could be sold to consumers at relatively low prices (e.g., $5-$10 per hit). The Clinton administration responded by legislating higher penalties for possession of crack relative to larger amounts of the powdered version. Crack and cocaine usage dropped as law enforcement broke up the South American cartels, only to have amphetamines and their derivatives replace that market.
Fentanyl and carfentanil are the latest responses to the globalized market conditions imposed by law enforcement. Heightened security at distribution points requires greater stealth by producers of these opioids. However, the unregulated status of these drugs creates the conditions for the kind of fatalities that we are now witnessing.
Imagine a society where medical professionals informed our responses to the natural human tendency to alter consciousness. Opiates would be available, by prescription, to those who are “clinically indicated” to benefit from the drug. The problems associated with drug addiction will not disappear, but the criminal organizations which depend upon prohibition will be put out of work.